American FinancialvsMorgan Stanley

AFG and MS stock compared: price, dividend, valuation and results, from SEC filings.

American Financial (AFG) has a market value of $13.4B and Morgan Stanley (MS) $303B. Over the last year, with dividends, AFG moved +19.4% and MS +14.7%. The P/E is 13.2 for AFG and 15.3 for MS. Dividend yield: AFG 2.14%, MS 2.26%.

At a glance

The main figures of both. A bar only shows which number is larger, not which is better.

  • Market value

    AFG$13.4B

    MS$303B

    MS is 23 times AFG

  • Revenue, 12 months

    AFG$8.5B

    MS$80.2B

    MS is 9.4 times AFG

  • Net income, 12 months

    AFG$1.0B

    MS$20.5B

    MS is 20 times AFG

  • Operating margin

    AFG15.2%

    MS–

  • ROIC

    AFG15.5%

    MS4.4%

    11.1 points apart

  • P/E

    AFG13.2

    MS15.3

    MS is 1.2 times AFG

  • Dividend yield

    AFG2.1%

    MS2.3%

    0.2 points apart

  • 5-year return

    AFG+63.2%

    MS+123.5%

    60.3 points apart

A fainter bar means a negative number. The 5-year return includes dividends.

The price over time

Both start at 100 at the beginning of the period, so the lines show how much each changed. With dividends means each dividend buys more shares.

AFG+63.2%

MS+123.5%

10020020222023202420252026
Returns by period
PeriodAFGWith dividendsMSWith dividends
1 year since November 12, 2025+19.4%Price +13.4%+14.7%Price +12.2%
3 years since November 13, 2023+75.9%+20.7% a yearPrice +49.2%+176.8%+40.4% a yearPrice +154.1%
5 years since November 12, 2021+63.2%+10.3% a yearPrice +15.1%+123.5%+17.5% a yearPrice +90.9%
10 years since November 16, 2016+325.0%+15.6% a yearPrice +100.9%+543.6%+20.5% a yearPrice +386.5%

Each cell: the total return with dividends, its yearly rate, and the price change alone. Before taxes and costs. Past returns do not predict future ones.

Every figure

As on each company's page. A description, not a recommendation: no one figure says which is better.

AFGAmerican FinancialMSMorgan Stanley

Valuation

AFGMS
Valuation
Price$161.02$190.65
Market value$13.4B$303B
Enterprise value (EV)$13.9B–
P/E13.215.3
P/E, 5-year median13.015.8
P/B2.82.6
EV/EBIT10.7–
Free cash flow yield––

Results and growth

AFGMS
Results and growth
Revenue, 12 months$8.5B$80.2B
Net income, 12 months$1.0B$20.5B
Free cash flow, 12 months––
Earnings per share, 12 months$12.26$12.60
Revenue growth, year on year-1.8%14.4%
Revenue growth a year, past+7.2%over 5 years+7.7%over 5 years
EPS growth a year, past+4.2%over 5 years+9.6%over 5 years

Margins and returns on capital

AFGMS
Margins and returns on capital
Gross margin––
Operating margin15.2%–
Net margin12.0%25.5%
ROIC15.5%4.4%
ROE21.5%18.0%

Balance sheet

AFGMS
Balance sheet
Cash$1.3B$244B
Total debt$2.0B$378B
Net debt / EBITDA0.3–
Interest cover13.9×–

Dividends and buybacks

AFGMS
Dividends and buybacks
Dividend yield2.1%2.3%
Dividend per share, 12 months$3.44$4.30
Dividend growth a year, past––
Buyback yield0.7%1.5%
Shareholder yield2.9%3.8%

Last 12 months from the latest 10-Q and 10-K. Value, P/E and yields at today's price. A dash means the figure does not exist or did not pass our checks.

Questions: AFG or MS

Didn't find what you were looking for?

Ask us
Which is bigger, American Financial or Morgan Stanley?

By market value, Morgan Stanley ($303B) is about 22.6 times American Financial ($13.4B), at today's prices.

How did AFG and MS stock do over the last 10 years?

Since November 16, 2016, AFG's price moved +100.9% and MS's +386.5%. With dividends: AFG +325.0% (+15.6% a year), MS +543.6% (+20.5% a year). Past returns do not predict future ones.

Which pays the higher dividend, AFG or MS?

The dividend yield at today's price is 2.14% for American Financial and 2.26% for Morgan Stanley. Over the last twelve months they paid $3.44 and $4.30 per share.

What is the P/E of AFG and MS?

At today's price, the P/E is 13.2 for AFG and 15.3 for MS. The median of the last five years was 13.0 and 15.8, which shows where each stands against its own past.

Which has the higher profit margins, American Financial or Morgan Stanley?

Over the last twelve months, the net margin was 12.0% for American Financial and 25.5% for Morgan Stanley, and the operating margin 15.2% and –. Revenue was $8.5B and $80.2B.

Which is the better investment, American Financial or Morgan Stanley?

The page does not answer that and does not suggest buying or selling. It puts the two companies' numbers side by side, from their SEC filings, for you to read and form your own view. The decision depends on your goals and situation.

Other comparisons

With each of the two, and with the largest in its sector.

Related pages

The other pages on US stocks, free to read. On the company pages, the last three fiscal years are open to everyone, five with a free account, and every year with Ploutos Investor.

Descriptive data from SEC filings and market prices.