ETF overlap

VCR vs XLY overlap - what they share and where they differ

VCR and XLY share 76.8% of their weight across 47 common positions, read from what each fund reported to the SEC.

Each week Ploutos reads the equity positions the largest US ETFs report to the SEC and works out the overlap of every pair. For each stock both hold, we use the smaller of its two weights.

VCR and XLY

76.8%

47 shared stocks

VCRVanguard Consumer Discretionary Index Fund

Holdings of VCR
Stock positions reported
276
Weight of the ten largest
56.1%
Only here, not in XLY
23.2%

XLYState Street(R) Consumer Discretionary Select Sector SPDR(R) ETF

Holdings of XLY
Stock positions reported
47
Weight of the ten largest
69.2%
Only here, not in VCR
0.0%
Positions coveredVCR 100%XLY 100%Filings: Aug 31, 2026, Jun 30, 2026

VCR vs XLY side by side

The same figures from the two funds' filings, side by side.

Largest sectors for both funds

VCRXLY
  • Consumer cyclical: VCR 93.6%, XLY 98.9%
  • Industrials: VCR 2.3%, XLY 0.0%
  • Technology: VCR 1.6%, XLY 1.0%
  • Basic materials: VCR 0.7%, XLY 0.0%
  • Communication services: VCR 0.4%, XLY 0.0%
  • Consumer defensive: VCR 0.4%, XLY 0.0%

The widest gap is Consumer cyclical: XLY has 5.4 points more of it.

  • Filing date
    VCRAug 31, 2026
  • Stock positions reported
    VCR276
  • Weight of the ten largest
    VCR56.1%
  • Largest position
    VCRAMZN 22.0%
  • Held alone
    VCR229 positions, 23.2%
  • Covered by stock positions
    VCR100%

What each holds alone

The heaviest positions one fund reports and the other does not.

Only in VCR

229 positions only here, 23.2% of the fund

  • MELIMercadoLibre Inc1.37%
  • SNSharkNinja Inc0.36%
  • Tempur Sealy International Inc0.33%
  • RIVNRivian Automotive Inc0.31%
  • BURLBurlington Stores Inc0.30%
  • FLUTFlutter Entertainment PLC0.30%
  • ARMKAramark0.29%
  • FIVEFive Below Inc0.27%
  • TOLToll Brothers Inc0.27%
  • BWABorgWarner Inc0.26%

Only in XLY

Every stock it holds is in VCR too.

Holdings they share

47 shared stocks
  • AMZNAmazon.com Inc
    Counted21.98%
  • TSLATesla Inc
    Counted15.43%
  • HDHome Depot Inc/The
    Counted4.88%
  • MCDMcDonald's Corp
    Counted2.82%
  • BKNGBooking Holdings Inc
    Counted2.43%
  • TJXTJX Cos Inc/The
    Counted2.25%
  • SBUXStarbucks Corp
    Counted1.84%
  • LOWLowe's Cos Inc
    Counted1.74%
  • DASHDoorDash Inc
    Counted1.39%
  • GMGeneral Motors Co
    Counted1.25%

Questions people ask

Didn't find what you were looking for?

Ask us
Is VCR the same as XLY?

76.8% of their weight sits in the same 47 holdings. VCR also reports MELI, SN, TEMPUR SEALY INTERNATIONAL INC, which the other does not. Among its reported positions, XLY holds nothing the other does not also hold.

How is the overlap between VCR and XLY measured?

For every stock both funds report, the smaller of the two weights counts, and the sum is the overlap. The reported positions cover 100% of VCR and 100% of XLY, so the number cannot exceed the smaller coverage.

Which holds more, XLY or VCR?

VCR reports 276 stock positions and XLY reports 47. 23.2% of VCR's weight sits in names XLY does not hold, and 0.0% of XLY's weight in names VCR does not hold. The ten largest positions are 56.1% of VCR and 69.2% of XLY.

How do VCR and XLY differ by sector?

The widest gap is Consumer cyclical: XLY has 5.4 points more of it. Sectors come from each holding's SIC code in its SEC record, summed by the weight the fund reports.

Where do the numbers come from?

From each fund's own N-PORT filing to the SEC, which lists every position and its weight. The comparison uses every equity position the fund reports; cash, futures and bonds are not counted, which is why a coverage figure sits next to every result. Holdings change between filings.

Related pages

Descriptive data from public SEC filings. Holdings change between filings.